The Recruiter’s Counter Offer

Sarah Byron-wood • September 13, 2017

As a recruiter, we are trained in how to deal with counter offers as soon as we start our careers. It’s the nature of our business. However I have a new found respect for how difficult a counter offer can be, due to my recent move from one of Australasia’s largest recruitment agencies to people2people’s new Auckland office. So after negotiation with both parties and talking to everyone in my life who would listen about the pros and cons of staying and leaving, it was the training I received when I started in recruitment which was the ultimate decider for me.

So here it is, the million dollar question; have your reasons for leaving changed?

Did you choose to leave just based on a dollar amount or was there more to your decision? For me it was culture and progression. I knew that while I could stay in the safety of my former position, I had more chance to build my own reputation with a brand new business and I knew it was right for me, because, ultimately and more importantly, my reasons for leaving hadn’t changed.

So to those of you battling the counter offer, simply ask yourself; “have my reasons for leaving changed?” To my fellow recruiters, be gentle. This could be the biggest decisions of your candidate’s career and the best thing you can do, is support them and explain all their options.

Grow your career and team
Get in touch with Frog Recruitment

Auckland
   I  Wellington


In business since 2002 in New Zealand, Frog Recruitment is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. Located across Auckland and Wellington, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 RCSA Excellence in Candidate Care Award, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.

Recent articles

By Frog Recruitment December 28, 2025
Skills-first hiring is gaining momentum, with 85% of organisations now using it in some form. However, challenges around assessment, training and leadership alignment continue to limit consistent adoption. Explore what’s driving the shift and how employers can make skills-based hiring work in practice.
By Shannon Barlow December 21, 2025
Psychosocial safety is becoming central to job security in New Zealand, reshaping expectations around wellbeing, manageable workloads, and leadership responsiveness.
By Frog Recruitment December 7, 2025
A clear, practical guide to understanding post-employment obligations in New Zealand, exploring restraints, non-solicitation and non-dealing clauses, and how employers can protect their business while staying compliant.
By Shannon Barlow December 7, 2025
Explore how evolving job scope, also known as ghost growth, is reshaping employee expectations and workplace dynamics, and learn practical strategies for recognising and supporting modern role evolution.
By Shannon Barlow November 30, 2025
A clear and practical overview of why burnout is rising across New Zealand, what workers are experiencing, and the steps leaders can take to strengthen wellbeing, connection, and resilience within their teams.

Latest PR features